Charlotte, North Carolina – The Carolina Panthers have announced the firing of general manager Scott Fitterer after three seasons with the team. Owner David Tepper made the decision in light of the franchise’s new direction, thanking Fitterer for his efforts and wishing him well.
During Fitterer’s tenure, the Panthers struggled on the field, posting a 14-37 record overall and finishing the 2023 season with a league-worst 2-15 record. The team’s winning percentage under Fitterer stood at a dismal .275, the lowest in the NFL during that time.
Despite Fitterer’s efforts in the draft and free agency, none of his acquisitions were able to make a Pro Bowl appearance. The only exception was cornerback Stephon Gilmore, who made it as an alternate in the 2021 season.
One notable move by Fitterer was the Panthers’ trade with the Chicago Bears, which secured them the first pick in the 2023 NFL Draft. However, their selection, quarterback Bryce Young, struggled in his rookie season with low passing yards, few touchdowns, and multiple interceptions. Furthermore, the Panthers’ poor record resulted in the Bears acquiring the number one pick in the 2024 draft.
Fitterer, a former minor-league pitcher in the Toronto Blue Jays organization, was known for his ability to collaborate and build consensus. However, his tenure was marked by limitations due to the team’s previous coach, Matt Rhule, having control over personnel decisions.
Tepper’s decision to fire Fitterer comes as no surprise considering his history of dismissing coaches and team officials. Although traditionally he has not let go of both the coach and general manager simultaneously, the Panthers’ abysmal 2-15 record, coupled with the worst offense in the league, prompted this unprecedented move.
Looking ahead, Tepper may use this opportunity to reorganize the front office, potentially by adding a senior vice president of football operations to act as a liaison between Tepper and the coach/general manager. Speculation has arisen regarding Dawn Aponte, the NFL’s chief administrator of football operations, as a potential candidate for this role.
As for the general manager position, one individual to watch is Brandt Tillis, the Kansas City Chiefs’ vice president of football operations. Tillis previously interviewed for the Panthers’ GM position and possesses a background in analytics, salary cap management, and roster strategy, qualities that align with Tepper’s preferences.
In summary, the Carolina Panthers have relieved Scott Fitterer of his duties as general manager after a disappointing three-season stint that saw the team struggle on the field. Fitterer’s tenure was marked by the inability to acquire impactful talent, resulting in no Pro Bowl appearances. Tepper’s decision reflects the need for a fresh start and a potential reorganization of the team’s front office. The search for a new general manager will be crucial in determining the Panthers’ future direction.